{"id":10612,"date":"2018-08-06T15:50:12","date_gmt":"2018-08-06T14:50:12","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/bogowiewojny.wordpress.com\/?p=10612"},"modified":"2018-08-06T15:50:12","modified_gmt":"2018-08-06T14:50:12","slug":"raport-bitewny-druga-bitwa-pod-manassas-battle-report-second-battle-of-manassas","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.gmboardgames.com\/blog\/raport-bitewny-druga-bitwa-pod-manassas-battle-report-second-battle-of-manassas\/","title":{"rendered":"Raport bitewny: Druga bitwa pod Manassas \/ Battle report: Second Battle of Manassas"},"content":{"rendered":"

This text is bilingual, the English version of the text is below the Polish version. The link to the video is at the very bottom of the text.<\/span><\/strong><\/span><\/p>\n

Ten tekst jest dwuj\u0119zyczny, Angielska wersja tekstu znajduje si\u0119 poni\u017cej wersji polskiej. Link do filmu znajduje si\u0119 na samym dole tekstu.<\/span><\/strong><\/p>\n

[PL]<\/span><\/strong><\/p>\n

W sobot\u0119 4 sierpnia zagrali\u015bmy Drug\u0105 bitw\u0119 pod Manassas. Do rozgrywki u\u017cyli\u015bmy oczywi\u015bcie zasad Bogowie wojny: Robert E. Lee. Komentarz do samej bitwy znajduje si\u0119 w filmie, kt\u00f3ry opowiada o jej przebiegu. Tutaj chcia\u0142bym podzieli\u0107 si\u0119 kilkoma przemy\u015bleniami jako obserwatora samej bitwy.<\/p>\n

G\u0142\u00f3wne pytanie to jak mog\u0142aby si\u0119 zako\u0144czy\u0107 ta bitwa? Limit liczenia morale armii by\u0142 wyznaczony powy\u017cej normalnego poziomu (25%), na 1\/3 strat podstawek. To znaczy, \u017ce obie armie mog\u0142yby walczy\u0107 dosy\u0107 d\u0142ugo. Z uwagi na ni\u017csze morale armii dawa\u0142o to wi\u0119ksze szanse Unii.<\/p>\n

8 tura zako\u0144czy\u0142a si\u0119 w momencie gdy ujawni\u0142y si\u0119 zar\u00f3wno korpusy Portera i McDowella jak i dwie dywizje z korpusu Longstreeta. Oznacza\u0142o to, \u017ce Unia mia\u0142a wielk\u0105 przewag\u0119 liczebn\u0105. W komentarzu po bitwie, dowodz\u0105cy Konfederatami Krystian deklarowa\u0142, i\u017c jego korpus Jacksona kontynuowa\u0142by dzia\u0142ania zaczepne przeciwko korpusowi Reno, resztkom korpusu Heintzelmana, a tak\u017ce Sigelowi. Prawdopodobnie pierwsze dwa z tych korpus\u00f3w ostatecznie zosta\u0142yby rozbite. Pozostaje jednak wa\u017cne pytanie jak du\u017ce straty przy okazji ponie\u015bliby Konfederaci. Zale\u017cy to od postawy Sigela w tej bitwie, kt\u00f3ry jednak musia\u0142 dosta\u0107 du\u017co kostek, \u017ceby m\u00f3c wykona\u0107 atak. Gdyby Sigel wykona\u0142 atak, to sytuacja w pobli\u017cu Sudley Mill by\u0142aby ustabilizowana dla Unii.<\/p>\n

Inn\u0105 kwesti\u0105 s\u0105 walki w centrum. McDowell i Porter dysponowali ogromn\u0105 przewag\u0105 nad dywizjami Hooda i Jonesa, w dodatku cz\u0119\u015b\u0107 dywizji Hooda zosta\u0142a ju\u017c rozbita atakiem Portera. W tej sytuacji Konfederaci musieliby wycofa\u0107 si\u0119 do Groveton i by\u0107 mo\u017ce dalej, po\u0142\u0105czy\u0107 z dywizj\u0105 Ewella i broni\u0107 przed atakami Unii, wykorzystuj\u0105c jej s\u0142abszych genera\u0142\u00f3w (jak to zrobi\u0142 Jackson gdy zaatakowa\u0142 osamotnionego Heintzelmana – decyduj\u0105cy moment bitwy ko\u0142o Sudley Mill). Konfederaci musieliby dotrwa\u0107 do ko\u0144ca dnia. Drugiego dnia na polu bitwy pojawi\u0142yby si\u0119 kolejne dwie dywizje z korpusu Longstreeta i umo\u017cliwi\u0142oby to rozpocz\u0119cie kontrataku. Wszystko to pod warunkiem, \u017ce bitwa nie sko\u0144czy\u0142aby si\u0119 drugiego dnia. Unia mia\u0142aby natomiast wyb\u00f3r, czy po wyparciu Jonesa i Hooda na zach\u00f3d, nie skierowa\u0107 np. jednego z korpus\u00f3w na pomoc Sigelowi, zostawiaj\u0105c przeciwko Konfederatom drugi z nich jako si\u0142\u0119 blokuj\u0105c\u0105. Wszystko to jednak zale\u017ca\u0142oby od rzut\u00f3w na dowodzenie dla unijnych genera\u0142\u00f3w.<\/p>\n

Wszystko by\u0142o mo\u017cliwe \ud83d\ude42<\/p>\n

Jak ka\u017cda bitwa historyczna wywo\u0142a\u0142a ona nie tylko du\u017co emocji, ale przede wszystkim dostarczy\u0142a wy\u015bmienitej zabawy. Bitwa przebieg\u0142a inaczej ni\u017c w historii. Przede wszystkim Sigel nie zaatakowa\u0142 Jacksona, tylko czeka\u0142 na przybycie Heintzelmana i Reno. P\u00f3\u017aniej ataki Unii by\u0142y prowadzone pojedynczo, osamotniony korpus Heintzelmana narazi\u0142 si\u0119 na gro\u017any kontratak Jacksona. Walki toczy\u0142y si\u0119 w poprzek nasypu niesko\u0144czonej linii kolejowej, a nie wzd\u0142u\u017c niego. Inn\u0105 zmian\u0105 w stosunku do historii by\u0142y ruchy Portera i McDowella, kt\u00f3rzy od razu ruszyli drog\u0105 na Sudley Road. Drog\u0119 Manassas – Gainesville zajmowa\u0142 tylko Reynolds. Takie por\u00f3wnania do historii to jedna z najwi\u0119kszych przyjemno\u015bci w rozgrywaniu historycznych bitew.<\/p>\n

W przygotowaniu mamy nast\u0119pne projekty, zatem obserwujcie naszego fanpejd\u017ca i bloga.<\/p>\n

https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/gmboardgames\/<\/a><\/p>\n

[EN]<\/span><\/strong><\/p>\n

On Saturday, August the 4th, we played the Second Battle of Manassas. W<\/span>e used the rules of the Gods of War: Robert E. Lee to play the game. <\/span>The commentary to the battle itself is in the film, which tells about its course. <\/span>Here, I would like to share some thoughts as an observer of the battle itself.<\/p>\n

<\/span>The main question is how could this battle end? <\/span>The army morale counting limit\u00a0 was set above the normal level (25%), for 1\/3 of the loss of the bases. <\/span>It means that both armies could fight for quite a long time. <\/span>Due to the lower morale of the army, this gave the Union greater chances.<\/p>\n

<\/span>The 8th round ended at the moment when the corps of Porter and McDowell as well as two divisions from the Longstreet corps appeared. <\/span>This meant that the Union had a great numerical advantage. <\/span>In the commentary after the battle, the Confederate commander Krystian declared that his Jackson corps would continue offensive actions against the Reno corps, the remains of Heintzelman’s corps, and Sigel. <\/span>Probably the first two of these corps would eventually be broken up. <\/span>However, there remains an important question as to how big losses the Confederates would incur. <\/span>It depends on Sigel’s attitude in this battle, but he had to use a lot of dices to be able to attack. <\/span>If Sigel made the attack, the situation near Sudley Mill would be stabilized for the Union.<\/p>\n

<\/span>Fighting in the center is another issue. <\/span>McDowell and Porter had a huge advantage over the Hood and Jones’s divisions, and in addition part of the Hood division was already smashed by Porter’s attack. <\/span>In this situation, the Confederates would have to retreat to Groveton, and perhaps further, connect with the Ewell division and defend against Union attacks, using its weaker generals (as Jackson did when he attacked isolated Heintzelman – the decisive moment of the battle at Sudley Mill). <\/span>Confederates would have to survive until the end of the day. <\/span>On the second day, the next two divisions from the Longstreet corps would appear on the battlefield and this would allow a counterattack to start. <\/span>All this would be possible if the battle would not end on the first day. <\/span>On the other hand, the Union would have chosen whether, after pushing Jones and Hood west, to send one of the corps to help Sigel, leaving the second as a blocking force against the Confederates. <\/span>All this, however, would depend on command rolls for Union generals.<\/p>\n

<\/span>Everything was possible \ud83d\ude42<\/p>\n

<\/span>Like every historical battle, it caused not only a lot of emotions, but above all it provided great fun. <\/span>The battle went different than in history. <\/span>Above all, Sigel did not attack Jackson, he was just waiting for Heintzelman and Reno to arrive. <\/span>Later, the attacks of the Union were carried out individually, the isolated corps of Heintzelman being exposed to Jackson’s menacing counterattack. <\/span>The fights took place across the embankment of the infinite railway line, not along it. <\/span>Another change in relation to history were the moves of Porter and McDowell, who immediately set off on the road to Sudley Road. <\/span>Only Reynolds occupied the Manassas – Gainesville Road. <\/span>Such comparisons to history are one of the greatest pleasures in playing historical battles.<\/p>\n

<\/span>We have more projects in preparation, so watch our FB page and blog.
\n<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n

https:\/\/www.facebook.com\/gmboardgames\/<\/a><\/p>\n

Link do filmu:<\/span> \/ Link to the movie:<\/span><\/p>\n

\u00a0<\/span><\/span><\/p>\n